<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1960181384305267&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

The Great Debate: Which is Better - eGift Cards or Physical Gift Cards?

In the realm of employee recognition and rewards, a pivotal question lingers: Which gift card type best captures the essence of recognition? Choosing the right form of gift card can be a strategic game-changer. This article delves into the age-old debate of eGift cards versus physical gift cards, offering insights into generational preferences, the power of data & statistics, and pros & cons of both. In addition, it will introduce the revolutionary Engage2Reward™ Choice Card as the ultimate solution to cater to diverse workforce tastes.

Generational Preferences Matter

In today's corporate landscape, understanding the nuances of generational preferences is crucial when considering the choice between eGift cards and physical gift cards for employee rewards. Let's explore the generational preferences:

  • Millennials' Digital Affinity: Millennials, known for their tech-savvy nature, tend to lean towards eGift cards. Their comfort with online transactions and love for instant gratification make eGift cards a perfect fit for their preferences.
  • Gen X's Experience-Centric Approach: Gen-X, on the other hand, values the tangible nature of physical gift cards. They appreciate the in-store experience and see redeeming a physical card as a memorable event, enhancing its overall value.
  • Baby Boomers' Sentimental Connection: Baby boomers often prefer physical gift cards due to their sense of nostalgia. They view these cards as a testament to personal touch, strengthening the emotional connection between giver and receiver.

Generational preferences significantly impact the choice between eGift cards and physical gift cards. Understanding these preferences can help you tailor your employee rewards program to resonate with a diverse workforce.

The Power of Data and Statistics

When it comes to gift-giving, the decision between physical and eGift cards carries significant weight, with diverse implications for both givers and recipients. Recent insights from market reports and consumer behavior shed light on the evolving preferences and dynamics in this domain.

  • According to a recent report, the global eGift card market is undergoing rapid expansion, with a valuation of $405.17 Billion in 2023, a projection to reach $740.41 Billion by 2027 and a staggering $1.5 Trillion by 2032. This substantial growth, driven by a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 16.3% from 2023 to 2032, is fueled by the widespread adoption of smartphones and increasing demand for advanced payment options.
  • While security concerns exert a slight influence on market growth, the market's fervor for innovative products is expected to be a significant driver during the forecast period.
  • In 2022, the digital segment dominated the market, accounting for approximately three-fifths of the global eGift card revenue. 


Giver vs. Recipient Preferences

  • There is a notable contrast in preferences between gift givers and recipients. While the majority of gift recipients express a preference for eGift cards, gift givers often lean towards physical gift cards.
  • According to a recent report, survey results reveal that a significant 94.8% of participants consider physical gift cards as the more socially acceptable choice.
  • This preference is often rooted in the perception that physical gift cards convey a greater level of thoughtfulness, while eGift cards may be perceived as a last-minute choice despite their convenience in online procurement.

Contextual Considerations

  • The preference for physical or eGift cards is context dependent. In business-to-consumer (B2C) interactions, physical gifts hold more significance due to their personal and tangible nature, fostering face-to-face interactions and heartfelt experiences.
  • In contrast, in business-to-business (B2B) scenarios, eGift cards emerge as a practical choice for large-scale gift-giving endeavors. They offer advantages such as ease of sending, immediate delivery, and a simplified purchase process, making them a convenient option for corporate gifting on a larger scale.

In essence, the choice between physical and eGift cards should align with the specific context and objectives of the gift exchange. Both options offer unique advantages, and understanding the preferences of both givers and recipients is key to making the right selection in any given situation.

Pros and Cons of Physical Gift Cards vs. eGift Cards

Employers often face the choice between physical gift cards and eGift cards when rewarding employees or clients. While both options offer variety of choice of brands, can accommodate budgets small and large, and are available in varying denominations, each option also has distinct advantages and drawbacks, making the decision an important one that is not one size fits all.

The Argument for eGift Cards:

  • eGift cards offer instant delivery via email or text, reducing costs associated with physical distribution, while physical cards involve packaging and postage expenses, which can add up significantly.
  • Managing a large number of physical gift cards can be administratively cumbersome from purchase to distribution to managing the receipt of them, as opposed to eGift cards which reduces the steps and allows for quicker access.
  • eGift cards offer the advantage of near-instant delivery, ensuring that recipients can access and enjoy their rewards promptly. Mailing physical cards can take days or weeks, delaying rewards and recognition receipt.
  • eGift cards are easier to distribute to a dispersed workforce throughout the country, state or region, in-office and remote employees.

The Argument for Physical Cards:

  • Physical gift cards are tangible and are perceived as a more personalized way to express appreciation or celebrate an occasion. eGift cards lack the physical presence that can trigger sentimental attachments or nostalgic reflections.
  • Presenting a physical gift card demonstrates effort and thoughtfulness, especially if it involves going to a store physically and selecting one that fits the recipient’s needs. eGift cards may sometimes be perceived as a more convenient yet less personalized option, as they often lack the tactile and personalized touch of a handpicked physical card.
  • Physical gift cards can create a stronger emotional connection as recipients appreciate the effort taken to choose and present the gift in person, or by mail. eGift cards are often perceived as last-minute gifts with minimal effort put in by the sender, especially when it comes to baby boomers and Gen-X.

Employers should weigh these pros and cons when choosing between physical and eGift cards. Both options offer unique benefits, making the decision context-dependent and strategic.

Give the Gift of Choice with the Engage2Reward™ Choice Card – A Digital Solution


The Engage2Reward™ Choice Card is an innovative card that offers a unique approach to the eGift cards vs. physical gift cards debate. Let's explore why this digital option is a game-changer:

  • Total Flexibility and Choice: With the Engage2Reward Choice Card, recipients can choose from over 250 different retailers for any eGift card of their choice in the Engage2Reward Platform. This flexibility empowers them to select rewards that truly resonate with their preferences.
  • Personalization: The Engage2Reward Choice Card allows you to add a personal touch with messages, animated greetings, and recipient-specific photographs. This level of personalization enhances the emotional impact of the reward.
  • The Best of Both Worlds: The Engage2Reward Choice Card bridges the gap between eGift cards and physical gift cards. It combines the versatility of digital cards with the personal touch of physical ones.

The Engage2Reward Choice Card is a versatile solution that offers flexibility and personalization, making it an ideal choice for employee rewards. It caters to the diverse preferences of your workforce, ensuring your rewards program is both effective and engaging. In a corporate world marked by diversity, the Engage2Reward Choice Card emerges as a beacon of innovation in employee rewards, making every gesture count.


As the great debate between eGift cards and physical gift cards rages on, one thing is clear: there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Generational preferences and the context of gift giving play a pivotal role in making your employee rewards program truly effective. The choice between physical and eGift cards ultimately depends on the target audience, the nature of the relationship, and the convenience factors involved in the gifting process, reflecting the evolving dynamics of gift-giving in both B2C and B2B settings.

There is a solution that bridges the gap between these choices—the Engage2Reward Choice Card. It provides the recipient with choice and can be customized to add personalized messages and videos, creating an experience that resonates across generations and fosters a highly motivated and engaged workforce. In a corporate world marked by diversity, the Engage2Reward Choice Card emerges as a beacon of innovation in employee rewards, making every gesture count. 

E2R Rewards Choice Card_v2


A better way to buy gift cards in bulk

Register today and get access to 250+ popular gift card brands, personalized customer service, and simple and secure ordering.


Subscribe to Email Updates